Welcome to our most detailed review on American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage review. In this review post, we tested this luggage set and have insights to share our experiences with you.
If you are in the market for a luggage bag, you probably are looking for more practical ones, seeing that traveling nowadays isn’t as easy as it once was. Maybe you are looking into getting a luggage bag that prioritizes your budget more than the quality.
Make no mistake though, quality is still king in the luggage business but more and more people are prioritizing practicality first, and for valid reasons, too. It simply is hard to justify a huge purchase for a bag that you will only use once or twice per year.
This doesn’t mean that you should sacrifice quality for affordability. That isn’t the case anymore, especially with how competitive the luggage market is.
You can still get a luggage bag for an affordable price but with as much durability as anything else on the market. That’s what this review is for.
In this article, we’re going to look into one of the most competitively priced luggage bags available on Amazon – American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage.
Not only is it cheap but it’s a package deal. You can get 3, 4, or 5 bags in one purchase. It is designed to be more of a family purchase kind of deal.
One purchase and you can get a bag for your whole family. They have 3 upright luggage bags in here, and 2 duffel bags, one with wheels. It’s one of those deals that seem to good to be true.
This is now the point where I tell you that this product is all true. It really is that cheap. But let me go further than that. In this review, I am going to discuss how this product was made possible.
How can a product be sold for so cheap? Did it sacrifice its durability? Is it low quality? These are just some of the questions I will answer.
And to kick things off, let’s start with the pros and cons.
Pros & Cons of American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage, Black, 3-Piece Set (BB/21/25)
Undoubtedly, this is the best part of this article. In this section, I will write both the pros and cons of this product to give you a better idea of how it performs. By giving you both the positives and negatives, it will give you a chance to balance the two out in your head.
This can help you determine if the pros outweighs the cons, and by how much.
Pros
Incredibly Cheap Luggage Bag
This item is one of those products that makes you double take because of how cheap it seemingly is, and you’re not wrong.
You are getting 3, even 5 bags for an incredible price of less than $150. To give you a reference, some of the more popular luggage bags out there fetch for more than $150, and that’s only for 1 bag, too.
If you consider the number of items you’re going to get, this product is an absolute steal. But of course, as with all cheap items, you might think that there is something going in here.
Perhaps the build quality is not that good, right? And that’s exactly what we are going to discuss in the cons section later.
Ultra Lightweight
All the bags included in this package are lightweight. This is one of those things that many luggage shoppers forget about.
A bag that is lightweight but durable allows you to pack more stuff in.
As for these bags, they seem to be durable enough to carry their rated weight, no problem.
But compared to their more expensive counterparts, there seem to be an obvious leveling off in quality.
To be fair, the price difference can be used as a justification for the sub-optimal durability.
10-Year Limited Warranty
Since this is an American Tourister bag, it comes with a 10-year limited warranty. Notice the word ‘limited’ was inserted in there.
It was put in there to sort of give them a way out in case they feel like the warranty is not fair to their policy.
For instance, they only accept warranty claims if the issue was directly caused by the defects in their manufacturing and material workmanship.
If the zipper falls out, that’s a good reason to claim an exchange or free repair.
As for other damaged that was caused by you, or by the airline company, the warranty is entirely in their discretion.
Reinforced Corners For Added Protection
Most cheaper bags ditch their standard quality measures to save money. That doesn’t look to be the case here.
Based from their claims, they still use the same quality control protocols for all their cheaper products. The main difference is the quality of materials that is used.
In short, you should still expect all the reinforcements for their stitching, lining, and all types of material workmanships inside the bag.
The only thing that should be different is the fabric used. To save money, it’s understandable that they use something a little bit more practical.
Cons
Now, here’s the part you’re probably waiting for. You’ve already read the pros, and to be honest, American Tourister Fieldbrook luggage bag is looking like a good buy.
In this section, I am going to help you determine if this bag is worth your business.
Are the pros enough selling point to make you ignore the cons? We’re going to determine that here.
Quality Issues
If you go to their review section on Amazon, you will read plenty of good reviews.
In fact, it has an overwhelmingly positive reviews, with an average of 4.5 stars out of 5. That is definitely above the average.
That being said, there are still plenty of reports with regards to the quality of materials used for this bag.
I’ve read reports of zipper being ripped open, wheels falling off, and handlebar breaking under extreme weight.
To be fair, these complaints make up only a tiny percentage of the reviews, like 1 in 25.
Needless to say, you shouldn’t expect this bag to be as durable as their more expensive counterparts.
No Built-In Locking Mechanism
In defense of this luggage bag, it is extremely cheap. This means that they had to sacrifice some features in order to hit a certain price point.
It just so happened that one of the key features they usually remove when cost-cutting is the built-in locking mechanism.
That is probably my most liked feature of luggage bags so it’s noticeable, personally speaking.
Unidirectional Wheels
The wheels for the luggage bags here are just standard in terms of design.
You can still work with unidirectional wheels, don’t get wrong. I mean, half the luggage bags you see on the airport probably still use them.
It’s just that, when you get used to rolling a multi-directional wheel, it feels weird going bag to standard wheel design.
I understand that they chose this standard wheel design for practical reasons but still.
It would’ve been nice if they had included this feature because in my opinion, it’s a good enough selling point for cheaper luggage bags.
Here’s a Short Video on American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage, Black, 3-Piece Set (BB/21/25)
Quality Rating
I feel like I’ve already talked at length about the quality of this item. It’s not exactly bad quality, but it isn’t great either. The build quality seems to be hovering in the average.
It certainly won’t last you a lifetime with everyday use but it can last you a very long time if you don’t travel frequently. So, I would give 3.5 out of 5 stars.
Size Rating
As for the size rating, it’s pretty obvious that this is going to receive a 5-star rating. You get 5 differently sized airport bags in just one purchase.
You can certainly find definite uses for each bag. If you don’t need to bring too many stuff, just use your carry-on luggage.
If you want to carry even fewer things, maybe the duffel bag. That’s the beauty of getting this group of bags – you can use whichever you deem is perfect for the occasion.
Feature Rating
Because of the competitive pricing of this bag, you really shouldn’t expect modern features in here. All the features on this bag are pretty standard, one that you’d expect from a bag this caliber.
Since there are really no noteworthy features to speak of, I would just speak about the quality of workmanship in these bags.
But bear in mind, you have to view this from a perspective that it is only 20% the price of premium bags. It’s one of the cheapest luggage bags out there.
Nothing really stands out in terms of craftsmanship, and that’s good. This means that everything is solidly made. Normally, for premium bags, you’d notice the attention to details, maybe double stitching, or an embossed emblem on the lining.
For cheaper bags like this, you won’t really notice details. It’s just a plain ol’ bag that does what it’s supposed to do. I give this bag a 4 star feature rating.
Brand Rating
I’ve reviewed items from this brand plenty of times before and I have to say that it is still continuing to impress me with their items. I am continually finding gem products from this brand.
This product is one of the many gems I’ve seen from this manufacturer. The fact that you can buy 5 items from this price point should be enough of a selling point to get you to consider it.
What takes it to the next level is they didn’t seem to have skimped out on the craftsmanship for their bags. Sure, they’ve decided to use cheaper materials for this bag but it is within reason.
American Tourister is quickly becoming my favorite brand of luggage bags for practical use. Not all of us requires fancy and ultra-engineered bag, to be honest.
Most of us only travel once or twice per year. In that case, getting the most economical bag seems like the wise decision. In that case, American Tourister is the brand to consider. 5 stars.
American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage Review: Product Specification
Product Dimensions: Wheeled Duffel 11.5 x 23 x 12
Boarding Bag 15 x 10 x 6.5
21” Upright* 21 x 14 x 7
25” Upright 25 x 16.5 x 8
29″ Upright 29 x 20 x 9.5
Manufacturer: American Tourister
ASIN: B07B6LSMQ1
Final Verdict on American Tourister Fieldbrook XLT Softside Upright Luggage, Black, 3-Piece Set (BB/21/25)
You have to understand that the main selling point of this bag is the price. Think about it, you are getting 5 bags for a price comparable to buying 1 bag from a more luxurious brand. When you think about this purchase, you have to take this fact into consideration.
But while you may think that because of the price, you will get a subpar quality product, that actually can’t be further from the truth. What you get is a well-built item with features you expect from expensive bags.
Sure, there are certain features that are missing like built-in locks, or even a built-in lock hole for the zippers, but that goes with the way this bag is priced.
This American Tourister luggage bag has a good enough build quality that will last you several years of regular traveling.
Truth be told, this bag could even last you a lifetime if you’re not a frequent traveler. I’m more a practical guy, therefore, my advice is to go always for practically unless you have money to spend.
Overall, I am giving this bag a 4.5-star rating based on the fact that it offers perhaps the best value for money in this segment. You will not regret getting this bag, and if you do, they have a good exchange policy so you’re covered anyway.
